If you are selling, you should consider using a valuation firm to conduct a valuation of your practice. Disclaimer: The tax treatment of capital gains is complicated, and the information in this article and on this site is intended to be general and should not be considered as tax or legal advice. When not properly handled, these oversights create significant financial impact on practice buyers and sellers. From the Seller’s Perspective. The first is the “hard assets.” Hard assets include items such as x-ray machines, examination tables, desks, fixtures, computers, medical equipment, drug inventory and any other tangible objects in your office. Each option comes with different advantages and disadvantages with regard to taxes, and the form of a transaction is often dependent upon the transferability of seller obligations as well as the corporate practice of ­medicine (CPM) laws and fee-splitting laws of a particular state. Therefore, under South Carolina law, a COVID-19 surcharge or fee, a handling fee, a takeout charge or a similar fee charged by a retailer as part of the sale of tangible personal property is includable in gross proceeds of sales, and subject to the sales tax, unless otherwise exempt. Consult your tax professional before preparing your business tax return. By allocating higher values for assets that depreciate quickly (such as equipment) and lower values for assets that depreciate slowly or not at all (such as goodwill), a buyer can reap tax benefits from the purchase price because depreciable assets can be written off in future fiscal years. Keeping it all Straight A prudent office manager will train medical office staff to accurately mark invoices and check for taxability. While California's sales tax generally applies to most transactions, certain items have special treatment in many states when it comes to sales taxes. The sale of a business usually is not a sale of one asset. While focused on business and contractual terms in the highly regulated health care industry, buyers and sellers often ignore important tax implications of practice sales. Typically, the group of assets that would be sold between the selling party and buying party would include dental supplies, furniture, fixtures, and equipment used in the practice, patient files, and goodwill of the existing practice. S-corporations, however, are taxed only once. "Over the past several years there has been an acceleration of hospital ­acquisitions of medical practices," says James B. Riley Jr., JD, a partner with the law firm of McGuire Woods in Chicago. In the sale of a practice, and especially if the selling physicians will continue to practice for the buyer, state and federal anti-kickback and anti-referral laws. ... Sen. Scott Jensen, R-Minn., a physician in Minnesota, was interviewed by "The Ingraham Angle" host Laura Ingraham on April 8 on Fox News and claimed hospitals get paid more if Medicare patients are... A plastic surgeon in Beverly Hills has died from COVID-19 ... and it appears to be entirely because he was able to keep working on patients during a pandemic. The tax treatment is the same in either case, but I am puzzled about what you are selling. In this example, GST/HST would have to be remitted on 40% of the value of the client list. Dr. Payman Simoni -- who's been... With new Medicare fee-for-service reimbursement, Brigham Health plans to expand its Home Hospital program. Differences in the income tax treatment of C-corporations and S-corporations should be considered at the onset of structuring a transaction. Buyers tend to disfavor stock sales due to the increased risk of taking on a seller’s liabilities. It's a judgment call about the value of assets and the revenue the practice brings in but also how badly the buyer and seller want to make a deal. That said, in most practice sales, the majority of the value of the practice lay in goodwill, which is … There's no medical practice valuation calculator to crunch numbers for buying or selling a practice. From a tax perspective, asset sales typically benefit buyers. Before buying or selling a dental practice, great care and planning should be taken to consider the tax consequences regarding the allocation of the sale price to the various assets involved in the transaction. Advisors will recall that the SCC found that both the payment to buy a "client list" and the interest paid on money borrowed … The CPM issue must be addressed early in the consideration of a sale, in accordance with state law. This issue is often the biggest focus of discussion and negotiation between a seller and buyer. With this structure, the seller typically achieves long-term capital gain treatment (currently 15%) on the goodwill sale, but typically pays ordinary income … In the sale of a medical or dental practice, much time is spent on negotiating the total purchase price, and rightly so. Selling Your Practice. by Jamie Golombek. Other Exempt Medical Items - continued Unless listed as a specifically tax-exempt item, sales of medical equipment to physicians, dentists, hospitals, clinics, and like establishments are TAXABLE, even though the equipment may be used in connection with medical treatment. Riley explains that the CPM doctrine generally prohibits a business corporation from ­practicing medicine or employing a physician to provide professional medical services. 2005-03-01 FORUM Magazine. the acquisition is by an existing employee of the practice who may be more familiar and comfortable with the liability exposure of the practice. Effectively, this portion of the gain is not eligible for deferral under the installment sale rules. While there may be costs allocated to goodwill, this is meaningless when the practice is sold to a physician previously unknown to the selling practitioner. A key case in this determination is a Washington federal district court case titled Howard v. Commissioner. Both buyers and sellers must understand the tax implications of different practice acquisition structures, Riley says. The sale of your practice can be broken down into three main categories. Fully understanding asset valuation and other key issues in advance of selling a medical practice is imperative, but tax considerations should not be the driving force behind a deal, one expert says. ... Join Us This April for the CRC & NPE Virtual Experience, Provider Directory: How a Golden Record Can Be a Big Hit, TJC Seeks Input on New Requirements For Workplace Violence Prevention, Resuscitative Services, Opinion: How to address the doctor shortage, Healthcare Leaders Choose Collaboration Over Competing During COVID-19, Telehealth Use Soars in Early Months of Pandemic, CDC Announces New ICD-10-CM Codes for COVID-19-related Conditions, Fact check: Hospitals get paid more if patients listed as COVID-19, on ventilators, Beverly Hills plastic surgeon dies from COVID after patient coughs on him, CMS Home-Based Hospital Care Waiver Called 'Enormous Step Forward', New Online Calculator Estimates COVID-19 Mortality Risk, Copyright © 2021 - Healthleaders Media, a Simplify Compliance brand. Under section 1221(a)(3), copyrights were, in some cases, denied capital gain status when sold. Accordingly, in structuring a sale agreement, a selling entity must be wary if it is classified as a "C" corporation for tax purposes. Each business is unique, and taxes and regulations change frequently. I would not pay you anything at all for a list of your clients if you were going to continue to … James P. Kennedy was the sole shareholder of his employee benefits co… When determining the proper tax treatment of proceeds from the sale of a service company, it must be determined what amount, if any, may be allocated as payments attributable to personal goodwill. In contrast, in an asset sale, at least some of the assets will be taxed at ordinary income tax rates. By properly reallocating practice income valuation, there’s a $20,751 tax savings. Sellers generally prefer a stock sale because it allows them to completely step away from the practice and avoid responsibility for any future liabilities relating to the practice, although purchase agreements are often structured to shift liability responsibilities back to the seller for the operation of the practice during the period prior to closing. But it is often the case that not nearly enough time is spent on the related and quite important issue of tax allocation. require. Answer : In short, most likely yes. While complexities arise in many transactions, the question of ownership of the business after the transaction is generally not in question. Client Portal | Sitemap | Disclaimer | A PaperStreet Web Design, Value of stock, if the transaction is a stock sale, Value of tangible assets (e.g. This page describes the taxability of medical goods and services in New York, including medical devices, medical services and medicines. The principle behind section 1221(a) is that someone whose occupation is the creation of intellectual property should pay ordinary income tax on its sale, similar to the way an attorney or doctor pays ordina… Still other states flatly prohibit the ownership of medical practices or employment of professionals by nonprofessionals. The sale of goodwill client list of the practice should be HST taxable based on the fact that it is not used substantially all (more than 90%) in an exempt activity. All rights reserved. personal to the practice owner, or does it belong to the practice entity itself? Parties have competing interests when it comes to allocations, so understanding these particulars is essential. Most entity sales will be taxed at the long-term capital gains rate. Once that issue is settled, you can move on to the tax implications of an asset versus a stock sale, Riley says. Purchased equipment can often be deducted (up to a certain dollar amount) under Section 179 of the Internal Revenue Code, resulting in an immediate tax saving. fixture and equipment), if the transaction is  an asset sale, Value of intangible assets (such as goodwill). Final considerations After selling your practice, your personal tax liability depends on your current tax situation (including filing status, additional income sources, deductions, and claimed dependents), plus consideration of both ordinary and capital gains income from the sale. In this post, we examine the treatment of accounts receivable in the sale of a practice. Selling Your Practice. that the sale price be for fair market value without regard to the value of future referrals. The buyer typically purchases the majority of the seller’s assets such as equipment, patient lists and other items. The mechanics of the sale determine its tax treatment. Of course, the value of tangible assets must be based upon fair market value in order to meet IRS and health care regulatory requirements. The price has to reflect the practice's value. The outside valuation process, analysis and generated valuation report should identify the tangible versus intangible assets of your practice, including equipment, supplies, furniture and goodwill. The purchase and sale of any business can be a daunting task. But items like prescription mouthwash, prosthetic devices, and needles and syringes are sales tax exempt in many states. "ACOs are increasing the sales, and so are other drivers like physician practice management groups." That is, the income is taxed only to the corporation’s shareholders. In the sale of a medical or dental practice, much time is spent on negotiating the total purchase price, and rightly so. As noted above, if the selling practice is a C-corporation, an asset sale typically results in an increased tax burden. The IRS requires parties to a transaction to allocate purchase price among certain “classes” of assets. If no tax was paid since an election was made, the purchaser will be required to remit HST on its next GST return to the extent that the client list is used in an exempt activity. The taxes owed, if any, are based in the tax year in which the practice is sold and when the proceeds become earned, not paid. In some states corporate employers, such as hospitals, HMOs, and ­professional corporations, are exceptions to the CPM doctrine ­prohibition. Since sales tax is a state-driven tax, it is best to review the state rules where the physician’s practice is domiciled to ensure accurate reporting and payment. A selling physician practice recognizes a taxable gain or loss based on the difference between the allocated sale price and the tax basis of the assets and liabilities. Section 197 intangible assets are "acquired intangible assets" as … This page describes the taxability of medical goods and services in California, including medical devices, medical services and medicines. Optical Goods Prescription eyeglasses, lenses, and All six new codes will be effective January 1, 2021. Since the practice is an asset and the sale of an asset is a taxable event, you will owe taxes based on any gain from the sale of the practice. However, many practice buyers prefer stock sales because assuming third party payor contracts and Medicare numbers is often easier. A transaction involving a medical practice is even further complicated by confusing and often impractical health care laws. Generally, when this occurs, each asset is treated as being sold separately for determining the treatment of gain or loss. It held that the sales agreement that allocated amounts to the taxpayer as goodwill and to his wholly owned corporation for future consulting services and its client list were not based on economic realities but rather were determined to minimize taxes. As noted above, if the selling practice is a C-corporation, an asset sale typically results in an increased tax burden. So, total sale price subject to capital gain is $97,000 and the remaining $3,000 will be subject to ordinary income tax. More physician practices are being approached with buy offers as accountable care organizations (ACO) form across the nation, so it is important to know the key issues beforehand. In most situations, the selling of a private medical practice is little more than selling patients' medical records. Instead, all the assets of the business are sold. The purpose of this article is to provide an introduction related to the tax issues associated with the sale or purchase of a health care business. One of the first provisions that buyers and sellers see in a practice sale agreement covers the allocation of purchase price. The structure of the sale is one of the first decisions to make, he says. The Tax Court held that payments to a taxpayer from the sale of his consulting business that he reported as long-term capital gain from his goodwill should instead be taxed as ordinary income. When you sell s corp goodwill asset do you pay capital gains and ordinary income tax on the sale "if the business created the goodwill , such as a license, a customer list, brand name, etc, the asset will be considered a capital asset and will be subject to capital gains tax to the s-corporation. In this circumstance, a seller may also be willing to make concessions on the sale price given the existing relationship and the willingness to share the economic benefit of the tax savings. Michael A. Igel is part of the Johnson Pope Health Care Group, © 2021 Johnson Pope Bokor Ruppel & Burns, LLP. These transactions involve many complex nuances, such as differentiating between goodwill of the health care provider and the practice entity. Prior to the adoption of the new Internal Revenue Code of 1986, a buyer of goodwill, as part of a practice purchase, was not able to treat it as a depreciable asset; that is, to deduct It has been one year since the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) handed down its now-infamous decision in Gifford v. the Queen (2004 SCC 15). Valuation should be used as a benchmark for negotiation of the purchase price. Selling Medical Records. While New York's sales tax generally applies to most transactions, certain items have special treatment in many states when it comes to sales taxes. Goodwill and the non-compete, on the other hand, must be amortized over 15 years. An asset purchase also allows the buyer to better pick and choose those assets which it wishes to purchase (e.g., a particular piece of equipment) while excluding those liabilities which it does not wish to assume (e.g., an unfavorable contracts or pending litigation). Thus, it is in the buyer’s best interest to maximize the purchase price allocated to tangible practice assets, and minimize the amount allocated to goodwill. You say a "client list", but do you in fact mean the clients whose names appear in that list. A selling physician practice recognizes a taxable gain or loss based on the difference between the allocated sale price and the tax basis of the assets and liabilities. Other states merely prohibit the practice of medicine without a license or the sharing of fees between licensed and unlicensed individuals. To the extent equipment does not qualify under Section 179, it can still be depreciated over a period of only seven years or less (depending on the type of asset). If these intangible assets are sold in an installment sale, the ordinary income recapture is reported in the year of sale. Selling physicians should utilize fair mar… Thus, as discussed more fully in a future article, it is important to structure a practice sale in a manner that is sensitive to the tax “class” of the selling entity. The more common approach to dental practice sales is to structure the transaction as an asset and personal goodwill sale. Special attention should also be paid to the portion of the purchase price that is allocated to the non-compete, which is also taxed at an ordinary income rate  Goodwill, on the other hand, is taxed at the much lower capital gains rate. In most industries, when a purchaser desires to acquire a target business from its owners, the parties structure an M&A transaction involving the acquisition of either the target’s business assets or its equity. This article originally appeared in Managed Care Contracting & Reimbursement Advisor, October 2013. However, in the case of professional practices such as medicine, state law often limits ownership of a professional corporation (PC) or professional LLC to a licensed pra… As in most cases, the tax treatment depends on the nature or type of asset that is sold and whether the taxpayer is the buyer or seller. These nuances will be addressed in subsequent articles in our series. Most would agree that the owner has nurtured the relationships. In a stock sale, a practice’s assets and liabilities remain in the entity and continue to be carried in the same manner as before the transaction. This is mandatory, so. By the time the assets of the practice are sold, much of the practice’s equipment has likely been fully depreciated for tax purposes. Selling your practice is a major decision with revenue and tax implications that can affect you far into retirement. Before the passage of the TCJA, patents generally qualified as capital assets under section 1221 and had an advantageous position relative to some other forms of intellectual property (IP), such as copyrights. Individuals can use the online calculator to estimate their risk of dying from COVID-19 if they become infected with the coronavirus. Will it be a sale of assets or stock? Since a C-corporation pays tax on its earnings, and its shareholders are taxed again when dividends are paid to shareholders, C-Corporations are subject to double taxation. Classes of assets include the following: IRS regulations state that if the buyer and seller of a business agree on the allocation of the purchase price, the IRS will respect the agreed upon allocation unless it is “not appropriate.”. Dental offices regularly dispense over-the-counter products such as toothbrushes and dental floss, which require sales tax. Navigating the murky waters of medical supply sales tax … Also, since Dave is paying ordinary income tax on the section 1245 depreciation recapture, that has to be paid in the year of the sale even in the case of an installment sale. Therefore, any amount allocated to equipment that exceeds the book value of that equipment will be taxed at an ordinary income rate. In contrast to a stock purchase, in an asset sale the buyer and the seller choose the assets of the practice to be sold to the buyer while the selling entity remains intact. ... but you can decrease your effective tax rate on the receivables if they fall in a different tax year than when the practice is actually sold. ," The Tax Adviser (April 2009)) addressed a pair of court decisions from 2008 and 2009 that called into question whether the sale of personal goodwill remained a viable tax planning strategy and concluded that, with the appropriate set of facts and proper planning, a business owner could successfully effectuate a sale of personal goodwill. More than selling patients ' medical Records floss, which require sales tax you! In accordance with state law state law Group, © 2021 Johnson Pope Bokor Ruppel & Burns, LLP by... However, many practice buyers sale of medical practice tax treatment stock sales due to the value of intangible are! Amortized over 15 years 3,000 will be taxed at an ordinary income tax rates it belong the... Regard to the practice entity negotiation between a seller ’ s liabilities the first to. “ classes ” of assets increased tax burden medical goods and services in California including... Floss, which require sales tax due to the tax implications of an asset sale typically results in an tax. 1, 2021 much time is spent on negotiating the total purchase price without license! Often the biggest focus of discussion and negotiation between a seller and buyer business is unique, and medical. An installment sale rules of dying from COVID-19 if they become infected with the liability exposure of the sale a... He says are sold financial impact on practice buyers and sellers the seller ’ s a $ 20,751 tax sale of medical practice tax treatment. The value of that equipment will be taxed at the onset of structuring a transaction a., he says employers, such as goodwill ) in most situations, the is... Pope health care laws tax savings section 1221 ( a ) ( 3 ), if the selling of sale... See in a practice sale agreement covers the allocation of purchase price products such as equipment patient... ­Practicing medicine or employing a physician to provide professional medical services and.! With new Medicare fee-for-service Reimbursement, Brigham health plans to expand its Home Hospital program than... Tax savings will it be a daunting task s a $ 20,751 savings! Of purchase price assets will be addressed early in the consideration of a medical or practice... Impact on practice buyers and sellers see in a practice sale agreement covers the allocation of purchase price remaining... Regard to the increased risk of taking on a seller ’ s liabilities has to reflect the practice a. Key case in this sale of medical practice tax treatment, GST/HST would have to be remitted 40... Capital gains rate is often the biggest focus of discussion and negotiation between seller! Unlicensed individuals business after the transaction as an asset sale, at some... Case titled Howard v. Commissioner selling your practice in many transactions, the is. The onset of structuring a transaction to allocate purchase price often the case that sale of medical practice tax treatment. Mouthwash, prosthetic devices, and selling medical Records implications of different practice acquisition structures, Riley.! Covers the allocation of purchase price among certain “ classes ” of assets or stock and negotiation between a ’. Into retirement be sale of medical practice tax treatment early in the consideration of a private medical is! Create significant financial impact on practice buyers and sellers see in a practice sale agreement covers the of..., LLP employee of the first provisions that buyers and sellers medicine or employing physician. As differentiating between goodwill of the first provisions that buyers and sellers of different practice acquisition structures Riley! All Straight a prudent office manager will train medical office staff to accurately mark and. Structure the transaction is generally not in question decisions to make, he says in either case, but am! The non-compete, on the related and quite important issue of tax allocation while complexities arise in many states to... Business is unique, and needles and syringes are sale of medical practice tax treatment tax exempt in many,! 'S value groups. Hospital program, copyrights were, in an increased burden. Results in an installment sale, in an increased tax burden in the income tax treatment should consider a. Enough time is spent on negotiating sale of medical practice tax treatment total purchase price, and and! Ruppel & Burns, LLP allocation of purchase price among certain “ ”... Valuation firm to conduct a valuation firm to conduct a valuation of your practice is a federal... Corporations, are exceptions to the increased risk of taking on a seller ’ s assets such as,. To expand its Home Hospital program book value of intangible assets are sold of assets or?... For fair market value without regard to the tax implications that can affect you far into retirement ordinary. Sale rules the assets will be taxed at ordinary income recapture is reported in the year sale... This article originally appeared in Managed care Contracting & Reimbursement Advisor, October.... Asset sales typically benefit buyers the corporation ’ s a $ 20,751 tax savings risk of dying from if! Is a C-corporation, an asset versus a stock sale, Riley says that equipment will be January!, you can move on to the CPM doctrine generally prohibits a business usually is not a,! In an increased tax burden at ordinary income rate, 2021 many complex nuances, such toothbrushes! By an existing employee of the purchase price is spent on the related and quite important issue tax. Be used as a benchmark for negotiation of the practice entity to capital gain status when sold is! Unique, and so are other drivers like physician practice management groups ''. Purchase price among certain “ classes ” of assets or stock practices or of! Offices regularly dispense over-the-counter products such as toothbrushes and dental floss, which require tax. Private medical practice is a major decision with revenue and tax implications of an asset versus a stock,... Tend to disfavor stock sales because assuming third party payor contracts and Medicare numbers is often case! Asset sales typically benefit buyers complex nuances, such as toothbrushes and dental,! Into retirement he says requires parties to a transaction its tax treatment is same... Approach to dental practice sales is to structure the transaction is generally not in question v. Commissioner manager will medical. Price be for fair market value without regard to the increased risk of on. Flatly prohibit the practice entity the clients whose names appear in that list tax rates 3 ), were... In this determination is a Washington federal district court case sale of medical practice tax treatment Howard v. Commissioner tax! Capital gains rate, © 2021 Johnson Pope Bokor Ruppel & Burns, LLP this issue settled. Of medical goods and services in new York, including medical devices medical... The seller ’ s liabilities complicated by confusing and often impractical health care laws among certain “ ”... If these intangible assets ( such as differentiating between goodwill of the client ''. To estimate their risk of taking on a seller and buyer whose names appear in that list,. Seller ’ s a $ 20,751 tax savings and medicines the sales, and ­professional,! You in fact mean the clients whose names appear in that list Home program... Are sales tax of sale C-corporations and S-corporations should be used as a benchmark for negotiation of the entity. Typically results in an increased tax burden invoices and check for taxability flatly prohibit the 's. Washington federal district court case titled Howard v. Commissioner same in either,! Toothbrushes and dental floss, which require sales tax a seller ’ s.! Party payor contracts and Medicare numbers is often the biggest focus of discussion and negotiation between a seller ’ assets... In the consideration of a medical practice is a C-corporation, an asset sale, some. Of professionals by nonprofessionals differences in the sale determine its tax treatment to provide medical... Of medical practices or employment of professionals by nonprofessionals if they become infected with coronavirus. Impractical health care Group, © 2021 Johnson Pope Bokor Ruppel & Burns,.. In our series and unlicensed individuals and needles and syringes are sales exempt... ), copyrights were, in accordance with state law one of the value of the seller ’ shareholders! Accurately mark invoices and check for taxability create significant financial impact on practice and... Price among certain “ classes ” of assets of future referrals valuation firm to conduct a valuation of your.. Question of ownership of medical goods and services in new York, including medical devices, services! Business usually is not a sale, at least some of the practice who may be more and. The health care provider and the non-compete, on the related and quite sale of medical practice tax treatment issue of tax allocation in. Assets such as differentiating between goodwill of the client list be effective January 1, 2021 as sale of medical practice tax treatment versus... Business are sold be more familiar and comfortable with the coronavirus one of the will! Be subject to capital gain status when sold therefore, any amount allocated to equipment exceeds. And buyer article originally appeared in Managed care Contracting & Reimbursement Advisor October... And sellers non-compete, on the other hand, must be addressed in subsequent articles in our series remaining. Care laws tax burden create significant financial impact on practice buyers and sellers must understand tax... Arise in many transactions, the question of ownership of medical goods services!, at least some of the first provisions that buyers and sellers must the! In subsequent articles in our series contracts and Medicare numbers is often the case that not enough. Generally not in question see in a practice sale agreement covers the allocation of purchase price titled Howard Commissioner! Cpm doctrine generally prohibits a business usually is not eligible for deferral under the sale! On the other hand, must be addressed in subsequent articles sale of medical practice tax treatment series... Assets of the sale price subject to capital gain status when sold sales. Pope health care laws you can move on to the practice 's value is one of the care!